Throughout the ten Ed.S. courses I have taken, the ones I have found to be the best examples of good design and the best quality instruction are those that included instructor-created video clips or multiple opportunities for interaction, either live or asynchronous. When learning completely online, these types of interactions provided the humanizing factor that “emphasizes the importance of the individual” (Moore & Kearsley, 2012, p. 137). I found the online trainings we did using Periscope to watch each other present to be one of the most engaging and unique activities because it allowed us to share a tool or do a training with a potentially global audience.
Image retrieved
|
I have also experienced a few not-so-effective online modules, one activity that comes to mind was a series of cases from a textbook that I had to analyze. The course had other well-designed components, but the time and effort required to complete this particular assignment did not match with the points available and there was limited feedback given. The design of this particular activity was flawed, but it could be adapted better for online learning so that it is more effective next time.To improve this activity, the point value needed adjusting to match the time involved in completing the questions. Another option might have been to divide the cases up among each student or pair to make it a collaborative cases project. To bring an interactive component to the activity, it could have a synchronous, web-based conference to allow students to present and discuss each case.
In all of my online experiences, those courses that included more teacher instruction using multimedia (not just text) and a variety of student interactions were most effective. Activities that required hours of reading and answering end of chapter questions for minimal points were least effective in my opinion.
References
Moore, M. G., & Kearsley, G. (2012). Distance education: A systems view of online learning. Belmont, CA: Wadsworth Cengage Learning.
I love your comment about the teacher videos with the cat. I use a similar program in my chemistry classes to show videos to students. One of the rules of flipped videos is that students want to see their own teacher. It does add a more personal feel to the course! I agree with you about some tedious assignments with low point values. Those types of assignments in online courses bother me the most. Moore and Kearsley (2012) even suggest using short segments that use up the time in a daily commute or "allow students to stop where they want to, providing a sense of closure and progress (p. 107). In my experience with online courses, the ones designed in this fashion have been the least stressful and most enjoyable.
ReplyDelete